Reviewer: broomstickflyer Signed 

Date: 07/17/2007
Title: Chapter 3: Chapter 3 - Final Fantasy
I have enjoyed most all your writing till I got to this chapter. In it Hermione seems to be vindictive rather than seductive and I feel that Ron though he likes her bossy would not like a version of Bellatrix in his bedroom, so for every thing else you wrote I can give you 10/10, but for this chapter I'm not even sure if I can give more than 6/10. Sorry but Hermione trying to force him to tell a lie dont wash.
Author's Response: Well, you are certainly entitled to your opinion, but I think you missed what she was trying to do. She was not trying to force him to tell a LIE but to tell what she thought was the TRUTH. It was written very clearly that she was having a hard time doing it, but she was desperate to get what she thought was the truth out of him. To compare what she did to Bellatrix is a bit extreme since she LOVES Ron and was not at all trying to hurt him. I don't think I've ever had anyone read that chapter and see Hermione's actions as sadistic and cruel because that is what Bellatrix is. Ron was enjoying it until he realized that there was a deeper issue. (Believe me, what she was doing is not very painful for a man, more frustrating) However, the fact that you don't like it is fine with me. I know it's not for everyone. I just don't agree with you comparing Hermione to Bellatrix. I still thank you for your review, not every one has to be stellar and not every chapter has to be a fan favorite. I happen to love this story since it's the first one I ever wrote, but I especially love the final chapter.